This cookie was a very solid top 3 for most of us. With a final rating of 7.75/10, when you exclude the outlier of a 1.2 rating. The consensus here was that the frosting was the best part and carried the cookie. The texture was great, with a solid cookie, obviously great frosting, and the crumbs on top finished it off very nicely. This cookie would definitely be suggested by most of us.
Mallow Sandwich Cookie ft. OREO:
This cookie was one of this week’s cookies; it was basically one giant OREO with a more solid outside crust and a smooth, creamy “mallow” inside. The taste and texture of this cookie were mid. Overall, this cookie was pretty mid, and it was not ranked very high, reaching an average of 6.22/10 from our group.
Not much of a “cookie” but definitely more of a classic yellow cake. The kind that your mom would make for your birthday. The frosting on the cookie was solid, but the sprinkles were a miss. They added a weird texture that didn’t mix well with the sheet cake. Overall, very moist cake with a good taste, we had an average rating of 6.96/10.
This cookie was one of this week’s cookies; it was a giant cookie with a lemon glaze and a lemon on it. None of us liked it at all. The lemon glaze was horrible; Jameson and Isaac spat the cookie out. The outside of the cookie was a little hard, with a soft chewy inside, but the glaze ruined it. The actual lemon was better. This cookie scored a 0.72/10 from our group.
Chocolate Crumb Cookie ft. OREO
This cookie is a classic from Crumbl Cookies and is offered every week at every location. It was a solid cookie with a good flavor and a nice, warm center, topped with cold frosting and crunched-up pieces of an Oreo. There was the perfect amount of frosting and cookie ratio. The cookie reached a consensus 8.7/10 from our group.
This cookie was a classic cookie from Crumbl Cookies and is offered every week at every location. It was a solid cookie with a good flavor and a nice warm center. There was a perfect amount of cinnamon and good texture throughout the whole cookie. The cookie reached a consensus 8.06/10 from our group.
